It’s Not Social Security Keeping Young People Out of Work
13 November 2026
Toynbee Hall’s research with Disabled people including young people not in employment, education and training shows that poverty, social disadvantage and failing services are driving youth detachment and mental ill-health. As Milburn himself says in the report,
“In a survey carried out for this review, 84% of NEET young people said they want to find a job, education or training. I do not accept the caricature of a generation that is not interested in employment. I do not accept that mental health is simply an excuse. Nor do I accept that the answer is to tell young people who are struggling simply to try harder. These are myths. Sometimes cruel ones. Young people are not to blame. Institutions that should have provided opportunities to them are the ones that have failed.”[i]
It follows logically that if the problem is crumbling or failing systems, the solution is fixing those systems, not cutting vital income support for young people trying to cope with those inadequate systems.
Despite this, the BBC has reported that Milburn’s report will recommend cutting the main working-age health and disability welfare payments (Personal Independence Payment (PIP) and the Universal Credit Health Element) for those under the age of 25.[ii] According to the BBC report, there may be a new “additional cost allowance” for those with severe conditions in this age group among his recommendations, but the size and eligibility criteria for this is not specified.
Cutting young people’s welfare payments is counterproductive to the Government’s aims
- Welfare support already doesn’t cover the cost of disability: Our recent survey of 2,000 Disabled people found that PIP awards do not cover the additional costs of disability. Only 16% of respondents stated the PIP covered all their additional costs. Just under a quarter (24%) saying it covers very little or basically none of their additional costs. As one respondent noted “Being alive is beyond my budget.”[iii] Scope has calculated that disabled households need an extra £1,095/month on average just to have the same standard of living as non-disabled households.[iv] The average monthly PIP payment is £465/month across households and the new lower rate of the UC Health Element is £217/month leaving a significant shortfall. JRF and NEF found that 50% of people receiving the UC Health Element, “are either unable to heat their home, behind on bills, or have low or very low food security, compared to 11% in households not receiving any UC or Personal Independence Payments (PIP).”v
- Cutting income support pushes Disabled people further away from the workforce: The UK and other countries have previously tried cutting or reducing Disability welfare payments in order to push people into employment, and it didn’t work. Research into the cuts resulting from the 2016 Welfare Act showed that reductions in disability-related welfare payments did not increase employment but did exacerbate financial and mental health vulnerability of those affected.[v]
Similarly, when Denmark cut access to disability welfare payments for most people under 40, employment among 25-39 year olds with a limiting health condition group fell. This is despite the fact that the cuts were coupled with new multidisciplinary rehabilitation programmes and restructured wage-subsidised employment.[vi]
- Cutting income support will undermine the services that the government is trying to build up: It is a matter of basic common sense that if people are struggling for everyday economic survival, they are less likely to be able to appropriately engage with education or employment services or internships. However carefully the government designs new programmes aimed at bringing young people into education or employment, they will not be effective for people consumed with worry over paying for food or housing. JRF’s research supports this, outlining how, “negative income shocks can render such policies counter-productive by pushing people further away from the labour market.” This is through mechanisms including inability to afford transport, accreditation, childcare, computer access, or interview clothes combined with the mental health impact of constant financial strain.[vii] Income shocks also negatively impact people’s mental health and in turn their ability to look for work.[viii]
Given the government’s economic justification for cutting welfare payments, it is worth noting that if the services that it is building up are undermined by the very cuts being used to finance them, it will cost the government more in the long run.
- Cutting income support before services are running and effective puts the cart before the horse: The government’s own timelines show that roll out of new initiatives will span years. Additionally, research by the Learning and Work Institute has shown that in the first year of delivery, London’s Youth Guarantee Trailblazer, part of the national Get Britain Working initiative to address youth unemployment, moved 18% of participants into employment. While an impressive outcome, we need to consider the 82% who would not have had employment income during this year.[ix]
- Being young does not make disability cheaper: As a Disabled Toynbee Hall Peer Researcher stated, “Disability needs do not automatically change according to age; if you need transport support because you are disabled, you will need that at any age.” This common sense conclusion is supported by the Resolution Foundation which found that, “Overall, our survey evidence should make us hesitate about the idea of implementing a separate disability benefit system for young people, not least because the conditions that 16-24-year-olds experience are not especially distinct from other age groups, and especially 25-34-year-olds.”[x]
- Cutting vital welfare support for Disabled young people will result in serious safeguarding harms: The Work and Pensions Committee report on Safeguarding Vulnerable Claimants strongly makes the point that the Department of Work and Pensions provides a lifeline to vulnerable clients, and that, “Over several years there are known to have been hundreds of serious harms and deaths of claimants.” Given the vulnerable financial position that many young Disabled people are already in, there is every reason to believe that there will be serious harms for people if their vital support is cut.
Milburn is right in his diagnosis of the systemic failures holding young Disabled people back, but his proposals risk further entrenching systemic failures for young Disabled people. Addressing systemic failures will require substantial, sustained investment in the services and opportunities young people need to secure their futures. To be effective, these services must be coproduced by the people who will use them. But funding these improvements by cutting the very income support that young people rely on risks undermining their effectiveness and causing substantial harm. The government must stop turning to the social security system to balance the national budget. If it recognises that years of underinvestment have left essential services unable to meet young people’s needs, it must take a longer-term view of how to fund their recovery. This means considering the full range of fiscal levers available, including taxation and the government’s fiscal rules, rather than asking some of the most disadvantaged young people to pay for the services they so desperately need.
[i] Milburn, A. (2026) Young people and work: interim report. Department for Work and Pensions. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/young-people-and-work-interim-report/young-people-and-work-interim-report (Accessed: 11 November 2026).
[ii] Somerville, E., Eardley, N. and Mason, C. (2026) ‘[Article title]’, BBC News, 11 November. Available at: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cwn70l1628l0o (Accessed: 13 November 2026).
[iii] Disability Rights UK, Toynbee Hall and Commission on Social Security (2026) PIP Survey Findings. Available at: https://www.disabilityrightsuk.org/news/timms-review-sparks-fears-about-future-pip (Accessed: 11 November 2026).
[iv] Scope (n.d.) Disability Price Tag. Available at: https://www.scope.org.uk/campaigns/disability-price-tag (Accessed: 11 November 2026).
[v] Song, H., Piroddi, R., McHale, P. and Barr, B. (2026) ‘Health, poverty and employment effects of cutting income replacement benefits for the disabled: a difference-in-differences analysis of the 2017 welfare reforms’, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 80(10), pp. 829–836. doi: 10.1136/jech-2025-225477
[vi] Barr, B., Song, H. and McHale, P. (2026) ‘The employment and poverty effects of Denmark’s 2013 disability pension reform: A triple-difference analysis’. SSRN, 26 August. Available at: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.7672978 (Accessed: 11 November 2026).
[vii] Joseph Rowntree Foundation (2023) Inadequate Universal Credit and barriers to work. 25 July. Available at: https://www.jrf.org.uk/social-security/inadequate-universal-credit-and-barriers-to-work (Accessed: 11 November 2026).
[viii] Joseph Rowntree Foundation (2023) Inadequate Universal Credit and barriers to work. 25 July. Available at: https://www.jrf.org.uk/social-security/inadequate-universal-credit-and-barriers-to-work (Accessed: 11 November 2026).
[ix] Learning and Work Institute (2026) Evaluation of Central London Forward’s Youth Guarantee Trailblazer. Available at: https://learningandwork.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/Evaluation-of-CLFs-YG-Trailblazer_FINAL-1.pdf (Accessed: 11 November 2026).
[x] Judge, L. and Murphy, L. (2026) Hard truths: Rethinking Personal Independence Payment. London: Resolution Foundation. Available at: https://doi.org/10.63492/fswt870 (Accessed: 11 November 2026).































